The fragmented banking system, led to the widespread use of checks paving the way for the evolution of credit cards.

The history and evolution of money, lending, and consumer credit paved the way for the emergence of payment cards in the United States. In the U.S., the banking landscape was dotted with numerous small, local banks due to restrictions on interstate banking. This resulted in a fragmented banking system, which, interestingly, led to the widespread use of checks. The Federal Reserve's national check clearing system made this possible, and as a result, Americans became heavily reliant on checks, more so than other countries. Transitioning to another aspect, consumer lending and installment buying made their appearance early in U.S. history. This happened despite the religious and legal prohibitions on interest and usury. To boost their sales, merchants started offering consumer financing. In the postwar period, total consumer debt saw a steady increase, with revolving credit forms like credit cards gaining popularity. Payment cards combined lending and payment services, creating a more efficient platform for consumer financing. This trend capitalized on the existing American habit of 'buy now, pay later', even though some still had reservations about consumer debt. However, it wasn't all smooth sailing. Establishing a successful business model for lending on the card platform proved to be a challenge. Over time, payment cards managed to solve problems and reduce costs for banks, merchants, and consumers. They facilitated small-scale lending and borrowing without the need for costly credit reviews for each transaction..

Incremental innovations, co-opetition, and overcoming challenges made cards more appealing and ubiquitous.

In 1958, the banking industry decided to join the game. Bank of America led the way with the introduction of the BankAmericard in California. This was a significant milestone as it marked the beginning of what we now call "co-opetition". Banks started forming associations like Interbank, which later became Mastercard. Meanwhile, BankAmericard eventually evolved into what we know today as Visa. However, the journey wasn't always smooth. The industry faced significant challenges in the 1970s. High levels of fraud, regulatory constraints like usury laws, and the complexities of consumer lending led to substantial losses. But then came the advent of computer systems for authorizing transactions, which significantly improved the efficiency of card usage. The 1980s was a period of rapid growth for the industry. Banks managed to overcome the problems they faced in the previous decade, usury laws were relaxed, and the mass marketing of cards led to widespread consumer adoption. The market also saw the entry of new players like Discover, affinity cards, and airline mile rewards, which expanded the range of card offerings. The 1990s brought another significant change - the rise of debit cards. This was largely driven by Visa's signature debit and EFT networks' PIN debit. Other notable trends during this period included bank mergers, securitization, and the growth of the Internet economy, which boosted online card usage. Over time, incremental innovations made cards more appealing and ubiquitous. Yet, even 50 years after the introduction of Diners Club, cards still only account for 27% of consumer expenditures. The dream of a "cashless society" remains elusive. The revolution brought about by cards has been gradual, with steady enhancements that balance the needs of consumers, merchants, and issuers.

Payment cards have revolutionized financial management, offering convenience, a consistent lifestyle, and supporting entrepreneurship.

Over the past half-century, the use of payment cards has become increasingly common in our society, transforming the way we manage our finances. This change has been seen across all income brackets, although the adoption of card usage has been slower among households with lower incomes. The benefits of using cards are numerous. They offer convenience, save time, and provide new services for users. They also help in managing money more effectively by reducing the need to carry cash. Credit cards, in particular, have made it easier to borrow money, enabling people to maintain a consistent lifestyle throughout their lives. While the amount of outstanding credit card debt has been steadily increasing, it still represents a small portion of income and assets for most households. There has been some debate about the impact of consumer debt. Some people are concerned that easy access to credit can lead to excessive spending. However, there is no evidence to suggest that the use of credit cards has resulted in a decrease in savings rates. While it's true that some consumers may overextend their credit, the rates of defaults and bankruptcies have remained relatively stable. The use of improved credit scoring methods has made it possible to extend credit to a wider range of income levels. Furthermore, cards have played a significant role in supporting entrepreneurship by providing a source of financing where other options may be limited. The widespread use of cards is a result of a series of small innovations that have balanced the risks faced by issuers with the benefits to consumers. Lenders have had to navigate challenges such as adverse selection and moral hazard. However, strategies like credit scoring have made it possible to extend credit to a wider audience while still managing these risks effectively.

The acceptance of payment cards is a complex balance of merchant competition, consumer preference, and cost management.

The journey of how payment cards have become widely accepted by merchants over time began with high-end restaurants, which then spread to hotels, car rentals, department stores, supermarkets, and other retail outlets. The advent of online shopping further propelled the use of cards, as more and more consumers preferred this mode of payment. Technological advancements in authorization systems, billing services, and card technology also played a significant role, making the acceptance of cards faster and more cost-effective for merchants. From a merchant's perspective, accepting cards can boost sales, as it attracts customers who prefer to pay with cards. However, it's not all rosy; there are costs involved, such as merchant discounts and processing time. Therefore, merchants have to strike a balance, weighing the potential profits from increased sales against these costs. The widespread acceptance of cards is largely driven by competition. If one merchant accepts cards, others feel compelled to do the same to stay in the game. However, it's important to note that there are still areas where card usage is less prevalent. These include services, rent, utilities, and business-to-business payments. To bridge this gap, new products like purchasing cards are being introduced. While merchants would prefer to pay less for card acceptance, most costs are borne by them rather than the cardholders due to the dynamics of the two-sided market. This has led to some resistance from merchants, with some resorting to boycotts and lawsuits in an attempt to lower their costs. There's a school of thought that suggests that the competition among merchants leads to excessive card acceptance, which in turn increases costs for all consumers, including those who pay with cash. However, research has found this theory difficult to quantify and address practically. Despite this, the acceptance and use of cards continue to grow, albeit gradually. Even after 50 years, not all merchants accept cards. The growth of cards is a testament to the ongoing effort to balance the needs of both merchants and consumers.

Multisided platform economics, balancing the needs of different customer groups through strategic pricing, is pivotal to the evolution and competition within industries like the payment card sector.

Imagine a marketplace where two or more distinct customer groups interact and benefit from each other. This is what we call a multisided platform. The goal of these platforms is to attract all parties involved by implementing pricing strategies that consider the interplay and mutual benefits between the groups. Take payment cards as an example. They represent a perfect two-sided platform, where the two sides are cardholders and merchants. The system primarily generates revenue from merchants while offering services to cardholders for free or at a minimal cost to encourage usage. The challenge here is to balance the needs and pricing for both sides. For instance, standalone systems like American Express balance this by offering merchant discounts and charging cardholder fees. On the other hand, collaborative platforms like Visa and Mastercard use interchange fees between members to maintain this equilibrium. Now, let's look at how pricing dynamics evolve for these platforms over time. As they enter the market, gain a significant user base, and start competing with alternatives, their pricing strategies adapt. We also need to consider multi-homing (where users engage with multiple platforms), variations in business models, and how different platforms interact with each other. Competition among payment systems with different models, such as charge cards versus credit cards or card networks versus Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) networks, creates a dynamic environment with constant pricing pressures. By understanding the economics of multisided platforms, we gain valuable insights into payment card pricing, strategy, competition, and innovation. The ability to balance the demands of cardholders and merchants through optimal pricing has been a key factor in the growth and evolution of the payment card industry.

There are co-opetitive systems like Visa and Mastercard, which foster innovation through cooperation, and go-it-alone systems like American Express, which offer rapid response but risk strategic errors.

In the payment card industry we can see two distinct types of systems at play. On one hand, we have co-opetitive systems like Visa and Mastercard. These systems are unique because they are jointly owned by their member banks. These banks are in competition with each other, but they also cooperate on setting standards and managing the core infrastructure. This cooperation creates a large, interconnected network that benefits all members. However, it also requires intricate management to balance the competing interests of the member banks. On the other hand, we have go-it-alone systems like American Express and Discover. These systems operate under a unified management structure, performing all functions in-house. This approach eliminates the need for coordination among different entities, but it might also limit the scope for experimentation. Cooperatives like Visa and Mastercard face unique challenges. These include opportunism, disagreements among members, and difficulties in raising capital compared to for-profit entities. To understand this better, let's introduce the concept of business ecosystems. In the payment industry, there are four central hubs, namely the four major brands. These hubs interact with consumers, merchants, banks, processors, and other partners. Here, we see another difference between co-opetitive and go-it-alone systems. Co-opetitive systems provide a platform for innovation and intense competition among members. In contrast, go-it-alone systems control the entire customer relationship. They can respond rapidly to changes, but they also run the risk of making strategic mistakes. Let's look at some real-world examples of how these strategies have played out over time. The cooperative structure has led to rapid growth for Visa and Mastercard. However, American Express, a go-it-alone system, was slow to innovate. This suggests that centrally managed systems might reduce diversity and increase vulnerability. The payment card industry continues to evolve. For instance, American Express has started adding some partners to its system. It will be interesting to observe the relative success of these contrasting approaches in the future. This will provide valuable insights into the dynamics of the payment card industry.

The competition among major payment card systems shapes the financial industry through strategic pricing, advertising, and policy changes.

These giants of the financial world - Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, and debit networks, compete fiercely, using pricing, product quality, and advertising as their main weapons. Take, for example, the rise and fall of American Express. This story serves as a perfect illustration of system competition. Visa, in a bid to outdo its competitor, launched a successful ad campaign titled "And They Don't Take American Express". Not only did Visa target American Express, but it also set its sights on Mastercard, vying for the loyalty of issuers. But Mastercard wasn't down for long. It bounced back by attracting nonbank issuers, increasing interchange fees, and tweaking its policies to lure in major banks like Citigroup. Next, let's talk about the advent of debit cards. Visa championed signature debit, marketing it as a card that functions like a check. On the other hand, the EFT networks were busy promoting PIN debit. The lower merchant fees for PIN debit spurred merchants to adopt PIN pads. As a result, EFT networks consolidated, leaving primarily the Star, NYCE, and Pulse systems. The cooperative structure of Visa and Mastercard played a significant role in their rapid growth. However, it also posed a challenge as they had to manage the competing interests of banks. In contrast, American Express and Discover opted for centralized decision-making in a go-it-alone system.

The competition from various issuers benefits consumers through decreased prices and increased options.

There are four main types of issuers in this market - standalone companies like Amex, depository institutions, monolines, and nonbanks. These issuers compete fiercely by customizing card features and pricing to cater to a wide range of consumer preferences. The competition is evident in the variety of interest rates, fees, credit lines, rewards programs, and other features offered by different issuers. They are constantly on the lookout for profitable customers, using strategies such as direct mail and balance transfer offers to attract them. Looking at the market structure, it's clear that it's a competitive field. There are numerous issuers, and it's relatively easy for new players to enter or existing ones to exit the market. Consumers are well-informed, which further fuels competition. Over the years, the output in this market has seen rapid growth, with a surge in volume and innovation. This competition has led to a decrease in prices, which is a win for consumers. Despite some claims, the profitability in this market doesn't suggest any persistent excess profits. The discussion also touches on the issuance of debit cards. Unlike credit cards, debit cards are usually bundled with checking accounts and are not standalone products. The primary issuers of debit cards are depository institutions. Interestingly, the concentration of issuers is lower on a national scale compared to a local one. Debit cards are not as diverse as credit cards in terms of features. While rewards programs are starting to appear, they are not as prevalent as they are with credit cards. In conclusion, this exploration provides a comprehensive look at the competition and innovation among payment card issuers over the past few decades.

The payment card industry has transformed from bank-led operations to domination by specialist firms, leading to increased competition and lower processing prices for consumers.

The behind-the-scenes operations of the payment card industry, which includes acquiring, merchant processing, and cardholder processing. These tasks were initially handled by banks, but specialist firms like First Data Corporation (FDC) have taken over. FDC, in particular, expanded quickly through acquisitions to become the leading processor. There are other significant firms in the industry, but we'll focus on FDC for now. Banks realized that processing wasn't their strong suit. It was a large-scale operation that required substantial investments. So, they started to rely more on specialist firms. This shift led to a consolidation in the industry, with a few large firms now ruling each segment. But don't be fooled, competition is still fierce. Acquirers are constantly competing for merchant business based on price, and issuers have the option to handle processing internally. This competitive environment has benefited consumers, as processing prices have been on a steady decline. FDC has not only taken over processing tasks but also ventured into related businesses like ATM networks. They might even try to sidestep giants like Visa and Mastercard. FDC has positioned itself as a new pivotal firm, controlling crucial infrastructure. There's even speculation that FDC could launch a new payment system, which would reshape the industry structure.

Antitrust battles have significantly shaped the payment card industry, with disputes ranging from membership rules to interchange fees and merchant discounts.

Let's delve into the history of antitrust battles in the payment card industry. Initially, there were disputes about membership rules, such as whether banks could be part of multiple systems. This lack of clarity led to a variety of association policies over time. Moving on, we find cases revolving around interchange fees and merchant discounts. The associations defended these fees, arguing that they were necessary to balance the demands of cardholders and merchants. However, merchants saw them as an unfair practice of price-fixing. There were varying opinions on whether these interchange fees should be regulated or not. A recent case saw merchants, including retail giant Walmart, arguing that the honor-all-cards rule forced them to accept signature debit at higher interchange fees. This case was settled by Mastercard and Visa for billions of dollars, along with an agreement to separate debit and credit acceptance. However, the basis for the merchants' claims of damages has been questioned. It has been argued that courts have found it difficult to understand co-opetitive systems and two-sided markets. There's a warning against regulators stepping in and substituting their judgement for outcomes in an industry that, while complex, is competitive. In conclusion, we've taken a comprehensive journey through the antitrust developments that have significantly shaped the payment card industry over the years.

Emerging technologies, legal battles, and new entrants are poised to revolutionize the payment card industry, potentially disrupting its traditional structure.

The payment card industry is on the verge of significant changes. Emerging technologies such as biometric authentication, smart cards, and contactless payments are poised to revolutionize the way we transact. Legal battles have also led to shifts in business strategies, such as Amex's newfound ability to partner with banks. Moreover, new players are entering the field, including account-to-account payment systems and mobile commerce platforms. However, cooperative card systems, which have traditionally dominated the industry, are now facing greater challenges. Their rules of exclusivity are under threat, which could potentially weaken member loyalty. Furthermore, they are more susceptible to antitrust scrutiny compared to their integrated counterparts. There seems to be a shift towards new payment ecosystems, such as a potential franchise system by Amex, an integrated network from First Data Corporation, expanded roles for PIN debit networks, and emerging mobile-based platforms. It's still unclear whether these changes will collectively lead to a significant disruption in the industry's structure. The cooperative card systems have shown resilience over decades of innovation. However, they now seem more vulnerable to legal challenges, new technologies, and innovative business models. It's a fascinating time for the industry, as it could be at a pivotal point where the future structure may revolve around new platforms and competitors.

The rise of electronic payments and emerging technologies may lead to the potential replacement of traditional cash and check payment methods.

As new technologies such as online shopping, mobile payments, and biometrics become more prevalent, electronic payments are becoming more convenient and widespread. In many virtual environments, the old-school methods of cash and checks are no longer accepted. In fact, the usage of checks has already seen a significant decrease. For many years, there have been predictions about a society that operates without cash. While it's likely that cash will stick around for person-to-person transactions, its significance is expected to wane over time. It's possible that virtual money, guaranteed payment data, could become the standard. If this happens, it would mark a transition from physical to virtual money in just about a century. The surge of electronic payments can be attributed to forward-thinking entrepreneurs like McNamara who grasped the concept of two-sided markets, and to the banks that established cooperative structures to achieve the necessary scale. Given that electronic payments open up more possibilities than cash, it's reasonable to think that paper currency may not withstand this wave of innovation. The industry is likely to encounter more disruptions from emerging technologies, new business models, and changes in the law. However, this upheaval should prove beneficial for consumers and merchants. All in all, there's a compelling argument to be made for the potential replacement of traditional payment methods by electronic platforms.

Home

Paying with Plastic - Book Summary (2024)

David S. Evans, Richard Schmalensee

"Paying with Plastic" is a comprehensive exploration of the credit card industry, detailing its history, economics, and the impact it has on society.

Key Ideas

The evolution of the payment card industry started in 1950 with a few hundred Diners Club cards and has since grown into a global powerhouse, processing trillions of dollars in transactions every year. This transformation didn't happen overnight. It was a result of four major innovations in payment methods - metallic coins, checks, paper money, and finally, payment cards representing electronic money.

Payment cards really took off in the US, thanks to a fragmented banking system and a heavy reliance on checks. The ingenious combination of payment and financing services in credit cards sparked rapid growth in merchant acceptance and consumer adoption. Payment cards became a staple across all income levels, offering convenience and flexibility. Merchants also benefited from faster transactions and the ability to meet consumer demand.

Now, let's delve into two crucial economic characteristics of the payment card industry. Firstly, it operates as a two-sided platform, requiring participation from both consumers and merchants. Secondly, it involves a unique dynamic called "co-opetition". This means that while there's cooperation on some fronts like technology standards, there's also fierce competition in most aspects of the business.

The industry is filled with major players, including associations like Visa, Mastercard, and American Express, as well as issuers, acquirers, processors, and EFT networks. The competition is intense, with "system wars" between associations, "issuer brawls" for consumers, and "backroom battles" between processors. The industry's structure and practices have also been shaped by antitrust litigation.

As we look to the future, new technologies like smart cards and biometrics could speed up the shift from plastic cards to electronic transactions. Changes within the industry, such as the rise of First Data and deals between banks and associations, could signal a turning point. The most significant shift is the move from physical payment methods to money that is digitally represented and electronically exchanged. This is the future of the payment card industry.

"Paying with Plastic" by David S. Evans and Richard Schmalensee provides an in-depth analysis of the credit card industry, its history, and its impact on the global economy. The authors delve into the complexities of the industry, discussing the intricate network of banks, merchants, and consumers that make up the credit card system. They also explore the economic and social implications of credit card use, including the role of credit cards in consumer debt and the potential for fraud and security breaches. The book offers a comprehensive understanding of the credit card industry and its significant role in the modern economy.

10 Actions to Implement Learnings:

Understand Your Credit Card: Learn about the terms and conditions of your credit card, including interest rates, fees, and rewards programs.
Use Credit Responsibly: Based on the book's discussion of consumer debt, use your credit card responsibly to avoid falling into debt.
Protect Your Information: Implement the book's advice on protecting against fraud and security breaches by regularly checking your credit card statements and reporting any suspicious activity.
Consider the Impact of Credit Card Use: Reflect on the economic and social implications of credit card use discussed in the book, and consider how your own use of credit cards impacts your financial health and the economy.
Educate Yourself on the Credit Card Industry: Use the knowledge gained from the book to understand the workings of the credit card industry, including the roles of banks, merchants, and consumers.
Evaluate Credit Card Offers: Use the book's insights to evaluate different credit card offers and choose the one that best suits your needs and financial situation.
Understand the History of Credit Cards: Reflect on the history of credit cards as discussed in the book to understand how they have evolved over time and their impact on society.
Be Aware of Global Trends: The book discusses the global impact of credit cards. Stay informed about global trends in credit card use and how they might affect you.
Advocate for Fair Practices: Use your understanding of the credit card industry to advocate for fair practices, such as reasonable interest rates and fees.
Plan Your Financial Future: Use the insights gained from the book to plan your financial future, considering the role of credit cards in your overall financial strategy.

Want a high quality book summary? Send us your wish!

Heard about a book? Check the summary!

Find more than 1 million summaries!

We are building a new experience around books!

Discover, discuss and engage with books in new ways, powered by AI! Become an early adopter to fight the global reading crisis.

Discover the Snackz AI catalogue

Self-Help & Personal Development

Influence, New and Expanded

The Miracle Morning

Summary of Elise Loehnen's On Our Best Behavior

Das Café am Rande der Welt

The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People

The Laws of Human Nature

Discipline Equals Freedom

Limbi

How Life Works

So bin ich eben!

Religion & Spirituality

Jesus on the Mountain: A Study in Matthew

What Happens Next

The Norton Anthology of World Religions: Buddhism

The Triumphant Church

Atonement

Freedom from the Known

KJV My Promise Bible Hardcover

Relaxed

Holy Silence

"Me Grandad 'ad an Elephant!"

Politics

Die Neue Welt

Cobalt Red

Das Neue Land

Economists4Future

Machtmaschinen

Powerplay

Das erschöpfte Selbst

Kurze Antworten auf große Fragen

Propaganda

Wie hat Ihnen das Anthropozän bis jetzt gefallen?

History & Geography

Georgia

Theorien über primitive Religion

A Modern History of the Kurds

Theories of Primitive Religion

The Dawn of Everything

Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World

The New Testament in Its World

Abschied von Sidonie

Sapiens

Archaeology from Space

Psychology

Illness as Symbol

Nudge

Why Him? Why Her?

How We Learn

Kleine Philosophen

The Paradox of Choice

Warum es funkt – und wenn ja, bei wem

Tomorrowmind

Der Sympathie-Schalter

Selbstbestimmt leben

Science & Technology

The Sixth Extinction

Erneuerbare Energien zum Verstehen und Mitreden

Megathreats

Merchants of Doubt

Emerging Technologies in Food Science

Human Error

Megathreats

Methode zur Gestaltung zukunftsrobuster modularer Produktstrukturen aus Markt- und Produktionssicht

On Fire

Echtzeit-Praxis mit PEARL

The right book at the right time will change your life.

Company

Privacy

Imprint

Cookie Settings

Get the books directly into your inbox!

✅ New Release

✅ Book Recommendation

✅ Book Summaries