Libby is caught between traumatic memories of the murder night and fragmentary images that have haunted her over the years. She begins to doubt her own perception when members of the 'Kill Club' - a group investigating unsolved murders - raise doubts about Ben's guilt.

The Day family was marked by poverty, violence, and drug abuse. During her investigation, Libby uncovers dark family secrets and must face the possibility that the real killer was never caught, revealing complex family relationships and how the past shapes the present.

After her family's murder, Libby became a tragic celebrity. Public sympathy soon turns to distrust and sensationalism. The 'Kill Club' exploits Libby's story for its own fame, pushing her to the edge. Flynn criticizes the exploitation of tragedies and fascination with the morbid.