Patsy, as the eldest daughter of a prominent figure, grapples with the expectations and burdens placed upon her. She navigates the social and political intricacies of her father's world, witnessing firsthand the compromises and contradictions inherent in power. Her journey highlights the challenges of balancing personal desires with the responsibility of upholding a family name intricately woven into the fabric of a new nation.

Set against the backdrop of burgeoning American ideals, 'America's First Daughter' subtly exposes the limitations placed upon women in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. Patsy's intelligence and capability are undeniable, yet her options remain restricted by societal norms. Her internal conflicts mirror the larger struggle for female autonomy and agency during a time of profound social change.

Torn between her love for William Short, an abolitionist, and unwavering loyalty to her father, whose actions often contradict her own moral compass, Patsy embodies the complexities of love and duty. Her story explores the sacrifices made in the name of family and the enduring strength found in familial bonds, even amidst disagreements and disappointments.