The book delves into the motivations of those seeking a more genuine and engaged form of Christianity. It explores how the church's founding principles of service, social justice, and radical inclusivity attracted a diverse and dedicated membership yearning for a deeper connection to their faith and community. The book examines the joys and struggles of living out these ideals in daily life, especially in the face of internal disagreements and external pressures.

Griswold deftly navigates the delicate balance of power within a religious community. As Circle of Hope undergoes a period of intense introspection and transformation, long-held hierarchies are challenged, and new voices emerge demanding to be heard. The book examines the challenges of creating a truly egalitarian and participatory model of leadership within a historically hierarchical institution.

At the heart of 'Circle of Hope' lies the question of how to reconcile deeply held religious beliefs with the pursuit of social justice in a deeply divided world. The book examines how the congregation grapples with issues of race, class, and inequality, navigating the complexities of faith-based activism.