After fleeing a life of judgment and rejection, Ivy is drawn to the acceptance and purpose offered by The Community. This unconventional family, however, soon reveals its true nature: a controlling and manipulative environment led by the enigmatic Joel. The novel explores the fine line between belonging and blind obedience, questioning the price of unconditional love within a community built on secrets.

Forbidden from reading after the age of fifteen, Mia finds solace and inspiration in the books she secretly borrows from the local library. These stories become a lifeline, offering her a window to the outside world and fueling her desire for a different life. Through Mia, Hoffman highlights how narratives, even fictional ones, can empower individuals to challenge their reality and fight for a brighter future.

Despite their vastly different experiences, Ivy and Mia share an unyielding love that transcends the confines of The Community. While Ivy grapples with guilt and fear, Mia's youthful idealism and courage push her mother to confront the truth and fight for their freedom. This complex relationship forms the emotional core of the novel, emphasizing the enduring strength and resilience found within familial bonds.