Walters masterfully obscures the line between truth and deception. Olive, through letters and interviews, presents her version of events, casting doubt on her guilt. Rosalind, initially determined to expose Olive as a manipulative monster, finds herself questioning the evidence and the motives of those surrounding the case.

The novel delves into the complexities of justice, particularly within the confines of the legal system. As Rosalind investigates, she uncovers hidden agendas and past grievances, questioning if true justice can be achieved through traditional means.

The novel explores whether someone who committed heinous acts can be redeemed. Olive seeks atonement through her art while expressing remorse, and Rosalind struggles with her own capacity for forgiveness as she witnesses Olive's transformation in prison.